• Staff
  • Board of Directors
  • Contact Us

Meridian Institute

Monsanto May Lose GM Soya Royalties throughout Brazil

Summary posted by Meridian on 6/15/2012

Source: Nature News (15 June 2012)

Author(s): Luisa Massarani

This article says that Monsanto may be one step closer to losing billions of dollars in revenues from its genetically modified (GM) “Roundup Ready” soybeans, following a ruling this week by the Brazilian Supreme Court of Justice. Since the legalization of Roundup Ready soybeans in Brazil in 2005, Monsanto has charged Brazilian farmers 2 percent of their sales of the GM soybeans, which now account for an estimated 85 percent of the nation’s soya-bean crop. The company also tests Brazilian soybeans that are sold as non-GM. If they turn out to be Roundup Ready, the company charges the farmers responsible for the crops some 3 percent of their sales. In 2009, a consortium of farming syndicates from the Brazilian state of Rio Grande do Sul mounted a legal challenge to these levies, arguing that they are effectively an unjust tax on their businesses, and that it has proved impossible to keep Roundup Ready soybeans separate from conventional varieties. In April, Giovanni Conti, a judge in Rio Grande do Sul, decided that Monsanto’s levy was illegal, noting that the patents relating to Roundup Ready soybeans have already expired in Brazil. He ordered Monsanto to stop collecting royalties, and return those collected since 2004, or pay back a minimum of US$2 billion. Monsanto appealed, and Conti's decision has been suspended for now, pending consideration by the Justice Tribune of Rio Grande do Sul. Meanwhile, in a parallel legal process initiated by Monsanto in 2011, the company requested that the Brazilian Supreme Court of Justice, the country's highest federal court, rule that the farming syndicates had no legal status to bring their case, and also that any final ruling should be limited to Rio Grande do Sul. But on June 12, the Brazilian Supreme Court of Justice ruled against Monsanto, deciding unanimously that the ruling by the Justice Tribune of Rio Grande do Sul, once it is made, should apply nationwide. Some scientists fear that if the company is forced to repay royalties, it could trigger cuts in funding for GM research. Brazil is the second-largest producer of GM crops, after the U.S. The article can be viewed online at the link below.

The original article may still be available at http://www.nature.com/news/monsanto-may-lose-gm-soya-royalties-throughout-brazil-1.10837

Food Security and AgBiotech News

  • Govt Approves Fines for Improper GMO Labeling

    RT (19 Aug 2014) (8/20/2014)

    The Russian cabinet this week approved a bill that introduces heavy fines for business people who violate the rules requiring obligatory marking of foods containing genetically modified (GM) products.... more

  • Court Rules in Elevator’s Favor in Biotech Dispute

    Capital Press (19 Aug 2014) (8/20/2014)

    A United States federal appeal court has ruled that Syngenta cannot force the Bunge grain elevator company to accept its Agrisure Viptera variety of genetically modified (GM) corn. Bunge, in 2011, had... more

  • Seeds of Doubt

    The New Yorker (25 Aug 2014) (8/20/2014)

    This article, in The New Yorker, profiles Vandana Shiva, an Indian environmentalist who is opposed to globalization and the use of genetically modified (GM) crops. According to the author, Michael Spe... more

  • GM Foods in Limbo in China as Safety Certificates Expire

    South China Morning Post (18 Aug 2014) (8/19/2014)

    The only safety certificates issued by the Chinese Ministry of Agriculture for genetically modified (GM) staple food crops expired this week, with no sign the documents will be renewed. The certificat... more

  • Plants May Use Language to Communicate with Each Other, Virginia Tech Researcher Finds

    Virginia Polytechnic Institute (15 Aug 2014) (8/19/2014)

    A scientist at Virginia Polytechnic Institute, United States, has discovered a potentially new form of plant communication that allows plants to share genetic information with one another. The finding... more

More News


Really, read some more.